How to identify 'off flavors' and smells in your beer
Brewing is not just boiling up some grains, throwing in some hops and bottling.
It's not that simple.
Brewing is a bit of science.
It's a bit of practice.
It's also a bit of experimentation.
Like GNR, all we need is a little bit of patience.
You can do all that right but sometimes it's still a bit of luck.
This is why when a brew batch goes wrong, it can sometimes be considered bad luck that your brew tastes like cabbage, butter or stinks of rotten eggs.
But is it really bad luck that your beer tastes like wet cardboard?
There are all kinds of chemical reactions happening in a brew and this is very normal and nothing to worry about.
It could be that for many brewers the smell of the hops over powers these smells and so when they are finally smelled, they get flagged as a concern.
For this brewer, I'd only be worried when it came time to bottle beer. And even then the first thing I would be asking is should I simply delay bottling another week? As every brewer knows, time is your friend when making beer!
There are many elements that can shunt the beer train off its brewing tracks, particularly improper preparation prior to making the beer and during fermentation and then bottling or kegging.
Working out what went wrong and what it means that you will be a better brewer for it.
And you know what?
The best way to learn is by tasting your beer and understanding what the 'off-flavors' of your beer are and how you might prevent them from happening with your next brew.
Here's a brief guide to help you trouble shoot common off flavors and what the smells mean for your beer!
When your beer tastes like green or rotten apples
I've never eaten a rotten apple but I know what a
sour green apple tastes like.
Tart and bitter.
In an apple, this is delicious.
In a beer, this probably means you have a fair amount of
acetaldehyde present. This chemical forms at the beginning of the fermentation process. The yeast will eventually convert it to ethanol (alcohol).
This is why it's good to let primary fermentation continue for a fair time and to
let your beer condition for at least three weeks. The longer you condition your beer, the greater the reduction in acetaldehyde that will occur and the beer your beer will take.
It will also help to ensure that you correct a fair amount of yeast. If there is not enough yeast present in the beer, it will take longer for the acetaldehyde to be converted.
Who cut the cheese?
If your beer has a cheesy taste, you're probably getting a sample of isolaveric acid. Often described as tasting like old socks, the acid occurs naturally all over the place, including, funnily enough, in the sweat of socks.
In the case of beer brewing this acid develops when the alpha acids in hops oxide.
The fix is too use fresh hops - both in leaf and pellet form and ensure they have been stored properly.
If you do find it in your beer, once again, let the beer condition further and this will mellow it somewhat.
Another way isolaveric acid can get into beer is
when you are using fruit. If you get a 'Brettanomyces' infection from the skin, you'll run into trouble.
What we do in the shadows
Ever heard of
skunked beer?
This is when a chemical reaction happens in the bottled beer due to over exposure to direct sunlight.
So named after the smell a skunk can release, 'lightstruck' beer is caused by the
UV radiation in light from the sun and retailer's lights.
The so-alpha acids in the beer (which come from hops) are broken down and form a new compound in the beer by joining with any proteins floating around.
This compound stinks!
The solution is to condition and then store your beer out of sunlight or from under UV Light (why you would be doing that anyway?).
Brown glass bottles are can preventing this from occurring as they can mute the effects of the light but not so many green bottles or clear glass. I have no idea why this occurs.
Refraction maybe?
So, the trick to avoiding skunked smelling beer is clearly to store your beer in the dark.
Funny how that's a solution to many of these flavoring issues eh?
This is why your beer tastes like wet cardboard
Here's the rule of thumb and oxygen when making beer.
Before primary fermentation, it's encouraged. During fermentation and after it's discouraged.
If this happens to you, you can't fix the beer. It is what it is. Drink it with some lime?
The only way to prevent oxidized beer from occurring is preventing it from getting into your fermenter. Ensure the drum or carboy is tightly sealed and that your bubble airlock / air vent has water in it.
When preparing the wort, oxygen is good because the yeast uses it before fermentation. When the yeast is doing its job, it doesn't need it
.
Rotten eggs !!
I once went to bottle a brew. The moment the beer came out out of the tap, a rank smell began to permeate throughout my man shed. It was disgusting, like some kind of vile stink bomb had been let off or I had dropped a case of
rotten eggs on the floor.
My brew was somehow contaminated. That rotten egg smell can most likely be identified as the gas
hydrogen sulfide - which was the by-product of fermentation gone wrong.
It is the by-product of the yeast strain or bacteria that have snuck into your brew (did we ever mention
you've got to sanitize your equipment?).
The thing about lagers and rotten smells is that all is not necessarily lost.
You can fix this problem if the sulfide was
produced by the yeast and
not bad bacteria.
Lager yeast strains are quite prone to producing sulfide odours. This is quite normal. If you properly condition your bottled beer (the
lagering process) by letting in stand for a few weeks, the smell should go away before it's time to drink.
Let your beer sit and be patient about it!
The news is not so good if you have a bacterial infection
I didn't tell you the whole story above. I was a very novice home brewer and I decided to bottle the batch anyway. I left them for a fair time and then cracked one open.
Did you ever make a volcano for a school experiment when you add baking soda to vinegar? You get an explosion of foam and that's what happened to my beer.
This was most likely caused by the unwanted bacteria continuing to work its own fermenting magic on the malt in the beer.
What a waste of time, energy and money!
So to prevent the smell of rotten eggs, you have to stop the infection from occurring in the first place.
Why does my beer taste like chlorine?
Or more rather, are you asking why your beer tastes like plastic or iodine?
You may also have a water supply that is overly chlorinated. If you used this to rinse equipment of brew with, that's most likely the cause.
The simple solution is to not use such water, however, it may be that kind of water is your only source. What can do then is either filter it or boil it for 15 minutes, leave to cool (we don't want you burning yourself or killing the yeast!) and then using it.
If you do need to use a chlorine-based bleach, then use no more than half an ounce per gallon of water and rinse with said filtered or boiled water.
Or move town.
Why does my beer taste like grass?
You could be forgiven for thinking we are just naming every kind of flavor there can be and say that it can be found in beer.
So forgive us when we say that beer can taste like grass.
This can be caused by using old ingredients like malt and grains that have been exposed to moisture. The best way to prevent this grass flavor is to use fresh ingredients and to store them in dry but dark places.
Or it could be that if you've used fresh hops, you've added too much leaf and stem material. It should be obvious what to do.
Grass taste should not be confused with some of the qualities that certain hops impart into beer. Cascade hops are often commented on by brewers as having this effect.
What could be the case here is that the beer has been hopped too long. It depends on what you are going for off course but a lot of home brewers dry hop shortly before bottling to try and capture as much hop flavour as they can. A beer that has aged for a longer time with hops may lose some of its zesty-ness and be construed as being more grassy than hops.
It possibly depends on how bitter the hops are as well.
Why does my beer taste like cider?
This one is a classic result.
One of the reasons home brewing in the 'bad old days' was because beer tasted too sugary
sweet like cider.
And what was the cause of this?
Too much sugar.
If you make your beer with too much corn or cane sugar, cider like flavours will develop.
Brewers
looking to increase the ABV of their beer will often add extra fermentables (extra as in more than the beer recipe required). Sugar is cheap and fermentable so they will add an extra kilo or pound of it and get the cider result as a bi-product.
What you can do is off course reduce the sugar and supplement with other fermentables like honey or more malt extract (DME) - basically
use more beer enhancer!
Help! My beer has nice fruity smells!
First of all, check that you aren't making a nice stout with raspberry because that would just be awkward....
Brewers often report that their beer smells like fruit - banana, strawberry, pear and even raspberry.
This fruity smell is quite likely to be an ester called
isoamyl acetate. The occurrence of it in beer is extremely common. Like many of the flavours and smells in this guide, they are a by-product of fermentation where the temperature was too high for the yeast, or there was too little yeast pitched.
Generally speaking, the higher the temperature of the beer, the more ester that is produced during fermentation. They are caused by acids in the wort combining with alcohol.
The concentration level of ester will also depend on the kind of beer that is being made. German style wheat beers and Belgian ales tend to possess theses as a deliberate beer aesthetic. Go Bavaria!
One way to reduce the production of esters in your beer is to use a tall and narrow fermenter than shallower vessels. According to the
American Homebrewers Association "this is because high hydrostatic pressure and levels of CO2 in the tall, narrow vessels inhibit ester formation."
We did say beer making was a science!
To remove your unwanted esters the solution you have to prevent them from occurring in the first place so try and brew your beer at the recommended temperature for your yeast, favoring the colder side of the spectrum. This is especially so if you are brewing a lager because esters to nod add to the drinking experience of a lager.
The other option is to overpitch your yeast to ensure that there is no deficiency >> a low amount of yeast tends to make the yeast work harder and produce more esters.
Finally, ensuring your wort is properly oxygenated prior to primary fermentation will help the yeast function as intended.
A final amusing point on isoamyl acetate is that it is actually used as an artificial flavoring for things like banana milkshakes!
That delicious paint thinner taste is a fusel alcohol
Now I've never drunk paint thinner but I've sure smelled them! They are strong and pungent.
'Paint thinner' is a term for solvents that are used to thin oil based paint or for cleaning up paint brushes and
maintaining equipment like chainsaws. They are usually referred to as white spirits, turpentine or acetone. Either way, you recognize them as smelling quite harsh - and you can imagine the taste.
While most people do not drink solvents, many brewers often report that their beer has a 'paint thinner' taste.
What is most likely the cause of this flavor are
fusel alcohols. They are sometimes referred to as fusel oils.
These occur naturally in home brewing and will occur at noticeable levels to the palate when the beer is fermented at too high a temperature of the beer is left in contact with the
trub for too long.
The way to prevent fusel alcohols occurring in your beer is to ferment at the recommended temperature for the beer you are making.
Most certainly do not leave your beer to ferment for a week in a closed shed at the height of summer! It will surely be too hot.
I have to admit, I made this mistake. It's so disappointing to discover when bottling your beer doesn't smell like when it started and a quick taste test reveals the truth...
Ensuring you use the correct amount of yeast can help.
If you have difficulty controlling the temperature of your brewing situation you could try using yeasts known for their
ability to handle higher temperatures, such as Belgian yeasts.
Letting the bottled beer condition for a good length of time will also give the fusels a chance to break down. It's not a guarantee of fixing the problem. If you have a mild case, your odds get better with each day of conditioning.
Here's some other common flavors and what they mean:
- Tart tastes can be caused by polyphenols which are caused by over milled grains that are steeped too long.
- Butterscotch or buttery flavors can be diacetyl and is naturally occurring. Affected by temperature and over oxygenation post pitching of the yeast.
- Cough Syrup - possibly phenol which can be caused by a variety of things including improper sparging and mashing techniques, temperature ranges, and sanitizers and cleaning products that utilize iodine or chlorine.
- Metal, pennies - a contaminant from non-stainless metal kettles and poor water.
- Salt - you probably added salt to your beer. Add too much and you wreck the taste balance.
- Soap - you probably added soap to your beer (again WTF) or you left it to soak too long in the primary fermenter and your beer is literally turning into a form of soap. No, you can't shower with it.
Final words
If you've made it this far, you will appreciate there are many factors and processes which can contribute to off flavors in your homebrew (and of course ciders and wine).
We haven't even covered them all!
Some of them occur naturally and will fade away as part of the normal practice of brewing is followed. Others will be fatal to your beer (such as a
bacteria-infected or skunked beer).
, you might be looking closer to a week. That said, many homebrewers report that a week of cold crashing achieves the best clarity results.